A 57-year-old Toms River man pleaded guilty Monday to shooting and killing a dog in Berkeley Township.
Jeffrey Lentz pleaded guilty before Judge Kimarie Rahill to Possession of a Weapon for an Unlawful Purpose and Animal Cruelty, both stemming from an October 3rd, 2025 incident, prosecutors announced.
According to investigators, the dog’s owner had left the animal in Lentz’s care. At approximately 9:05 p.m., Berkeley Township Police responded to a residence on Lyford Court for an animal call after the owner received word that the dog had been injured. The dog later succumbed to her injuries.
A necropsy conducted at the New Jersey Animal Health Diagnostics Lab in Trenton determined that the wound to the dog’s face was caused by a gunshot. An X-ray also revealed a bullet lodged in the dog’s jawbone. The investigation determined that Lentz had shot the dog, causing her death.
Lentz was arrested at his residence on November 3rd, 2025, and charged accordingly.
At sentencing, prosecutors will seek five years in New Jersey State Prison, with one year of parole ineligibility, for the weapon offense, and three years for animal cruelty. Prosecutors will also seek a lifetime ban on owning animals. The prison sentences are to run concurrently.
