A large crowd turned out both for and against a Pitney Lane shul application at Monday night’s Jackson Planning Board meeting, which ended without an approval or denial after hours of testimony.
The board voted 4-3 to carry the application for revised plans.
As TLS showed from the meeting Monday night, residents filled the room as supporters and opponents came out to address the proposal.
The application seeks a change of use from a residence to an approximately 9,600-square-foot house of worship.
During the hearing, the applicant withdrew a proposed 2,227-square-foot basement hall. That reduced the required parking from 52 spaces to 30, with 32 physical spaces proposed. Board members sought a deed restriction on basement use; counsel opposed that approach and offered a condition requiring the basement to remain unfinished. The issue remained unresolved.
Supporters said a walkable neighborhood shul would benefit local families. Opponents raised concerns about traffic, parking and stormwater.
Traffic engineer John Rea testified that the worst modeled delay would rise from 50.1 seconds to 53.1 seconds with the added traffic. The congregation was described during the hearing as 60 families.
The matter took up nearly the entire meeting, which ran about four and a half hours.



the synagogue benefits everyone, including those very opponents, no synagogue has ever chased away someone in need, most synagogues offer free study time and some sort of food distribution, others send out clothing vouchers, and in general provide a healthy and safe space for teens and preteens, along with the elderly who need social recognition to maintain a positive and healthy mood.
the ONLY thing the township should be requiring and providing are wheelchair ramps and a bike rack-
1- because the bad guys know to come and steal from innocent kids
2- because it teaches children to park respectfully.
3- it is safer for elderly not to bump into an e scooter.
any other discussion in like living in total denial of community needs and trends.
All it was, was a bunch of old ppl who don’t even live in the area. We need to keep these miserable ppl buy with a hobby.