New Jersey Drivers Facing The Largest Auto Insurance Increases In 2026, New Study Finds

New Jersey drivers are expected to see the largest increases in car insurance premiums in the country in 2026, according to a new industry analysis.

A recently released report by ValuePenguin estimates that auto insurance rates in New Jersey could rise by 10.46% when policies renew in 2026, the largest projected increase of all 50 states.

The anticipated increase contrasts sharply with national trends. Across the United States, car insurance premiums are expected to rise by less than 1% on average in 2026, marking the smallest year-over-year increase since before inflation-driven spikes earlier in the decade.

The states trailing New Jersey with the highest expected increases this year are Nevada, California and New York, all of whom are averaging 6% increases.

The report also found that insurance costs in New Jersey can climb significantly after accidents. Drivers in the state may see premiums rise by about 74% following an at-fault crash, with average monthly full-coverage costs reaching approximately $433 afterward.

One main reason for the increase is due to recent legislative changes which mandated increased coverage from $25,000 per person/$50,000 per accident for bodily injury to $35,000 per person/$70,000 per accident for bodily injury liability.

Rate changes will vary by insurer. Among midsize companies operating in New Jersey, NJM policyholders could see average premium increases of about 21.18%, while Erie Insurance rates may rise about 7.92% and Plymouth Rock premiums about 6.24%, according to the analysis.

New Jersey residents already face some of the highest housing-related costs in the country, with property owners in the state continuing to have the highest effective property tax rate in the United States, according to recently released state data.

And its not just insurance rates and property taxes which are going up in New Jersey: In the last month alone, tolls went up on every major highway and river crossing in the state, along with the state imposed gas tax.

Nationally, the report suggests the pace of insurance price increases is stabilizing after several years of sharp growth driven by inflation, rising repair costs, and expensive claims. Still, state-level factors — including regional claims costs, regulations, and insurer filings — continue to produce wide differences in how premiums change from one state to another.

The projections are based on rate filings by insurance companies in 2025 that will affect policies renewing in 2026, according to the report.

This content, and any other content on TLS, may not be republished or reproduced without prior permission from TLS. Copying or reproducing our content is both against the law and against Halacha. To inquire about using our content, including videos or photos, email us at [email protected].

Stay up to date with our news alerts by following us on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook.
Got a news tip? Email us at [email protected], Text 415-857-2667, or WhatsApp 609-661-8668.

11 COMMENTS

11 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Deborah
9 months ago

Geez I can’t imagine why.

Cereal
Reply to  Deborah
9 months ago

You don’t need to wonder very much.
The article tells us: it’s because of regulatory change by the state government in Trenton.

I know you were trying to insinuate that it has something to do with bad drivers on the road, but there are bad drivers in almost every state and in much higher concentrations in some cases than anywhere you’ll find in New Jersey.

Deborah
Reply to  Cereal
9 months ago

ocean county has the highest auto accidents and deaths. You must have missed that recent info.

shmendrick
Reply to  Deborah
9 months ago

Rates are going up across the state. There are other areas of teh country just as bad as lakewood, yet those states aren’t raising rates.

Asinine Commenter
9 months ago

New Jerseyans Facing Largest Increases In Just About Everything, New Study Finds
New Jerseyans are expected to see the largest increases in just about every bill, every premium and everything else they pay for, a new study finds.
The study was conducted by the NJ Institute Of Increased Pricing, which receives its annual increase in funding from NJ State’s year-to-year tax hikes and other forms of government-sponsored thievery.
“The primary reason for the constant increase in charges is due to the constant increase in prices,” says Bill Thinkman, a Professor of Economics in Ocean County Elementary School’s 1st grade class.
“If taxes are increasing each and every year, and companies and retailers are charging more for their services, utilities and products each and evey year, then, New Jerseyans are going to see a yearly increase in their payments, based on simple logic and rudimentary common sense,” Professor Thinkman explained.
“If you prefer, I could break down my analysis into simpler form,” the Professor said, “but I don’t think it’s necessary, do you?”
Likewise, the Professor told his first grade class that, “based on the same simple line of reasoning, temperature readings in the classroom will keep increasing all the way to triple digit numbers if Tommy, who sits in the back row, keeps turning up the theromostat.”
“Remember this fundamental rule,” the Professor told his first grade students, “when Tommy increases the thermostat reading on a minute-to-minute basis, the room temperature also increases on a minute-to-minute basis, which is why the number of students who are fainting on a minute-to-minute basis keeps increasing each and every minute.”

Cereal
9 months ago

If the main cause of the change is the increase in state minimum, then any driver whose policy limits were already higher than state minimums should not see a significant impact from this.

That will be very telling

Freehold
Reply to  Cereal
9 months ago

I have coverage over 600% the old legal minimum. No change in driving record. My insurance tried raising my rates 60% on my latest renewal 2 months ago, I asked them them quote a new policy( vs auto renewal with the same coverages ) and it went to “ONLY” an 8% increase.
If the legal minimum is higher you would think my underinsured motorist coverage would have gone down now . Not the case

Last edited 9 months ago by Freehold
The process at work
9 months ago

Mikie Sherrill is a natural born leader. She is dutifully carrying out the will of the voters.

shmendrick
Reply to  The process at work
9 months ago

Which voters?

A gemera lover
9 months ago

It will not stop unless we nj citizens do something about it , next year will go up even higher….

Rosh Moshav Letzim
9 months ago

Imagine being a goy in huckleton Jersey and your rates go up because Lakewooders are incapable of navigating parking lots.

Last edited 9 months ago by Rosh Moshav Letzim