Letter: When Did Liquor Become Something to Celebrate?

I am writing with a genuine sense of concern for our community.

This past week, I came across an advertisement in a frum publication promoting a liquor raffle, featuring an array of expensive bottles and presenting them as grand prizes. At first glance, it might seem like just another fundraiser or promotional campaign. But I believe it raises a much larger and more troubling question: What message are we sending to our community when liquor becomes the centerpiece of a public celebration?

We cannot pretend that alcohol abuse is not a serious issue in our frum communities. Too many families have experienced the pain, the tension, the embarrassment, and the devastating consequences that can accompany irresponsible drinking. Too many people know firsthand that what begins as social drinking can sometimes develop into a destructive problem. Our community leaders, rabbanim, educators, and mental health professionals have worked hard to raise awareness and encourage responsibility.

And yet, at the very same time, we see advertisements that glorify bottles of liquor, highlight their prestige and value, and present them as coveted prizes to be won.

Is this really the message we want to send?

I am not suggesting that every person who drinks alcohol has a problem, nor am I questioning the legitimate place that wine and other beverages have in Jewish life and tradition. There is an important distinction between responsible use and the glamorization of alcohol. But when we turn expensive liquor into a spectacle, when we market it as something prestigious and exciting, we risk normalizing an unhealthy culture around drinking.

Our publications are not merely businesses selling advertising space. They are influential voices in our community. Thousands of people read them, trust them, and look to them as part of the fabric of frum life. With that influence comes responsibility.

Imagine the message this sends to a teenager who sees liquor displayed as a luxury prize, or to a parent struggling with a family member’s drinking, or to someone quietly battling an alcohol problem. What might such an advertisement communicate to them?

We invest tremendous effort in educating our children about Torah values, kedushah, achrayus, and the importance of protecting our families. We speak about the dangers of addiction and the need to support those who are struggling. These efforts deserve to be matched by the choices we make in our public messaging.

We cannot condemn the consequences of a drinking culture while simultaneously helping to glamorize it.

Fundraising is important. Publications need advertisers. Organizations need support. But surely we can find ways to raise money and promote events without making liquor the star attraction.

I respectfully call upon our frum publications, advertisers, askanim, and community organizations to give this issue serious thought. Before accepting or promoting campaigns of this nature, let us ask ourselves not only whether an advertisement is permissible or profitable, but also whether it reflects the kind of community we want to build.

Our goal should not be to shame those who drink, nor to stigmatize those who struggle with addiction. Quite the opposite: it should be to create a community that treats this issue with sensitivity, maturity, and genuine concern for every Yid and every family.

We have the ability to set a better standard. Let us use it.

With sincere concern for the health and future of our community,

A Concerned Member of the Frum Community

Click here to join the official TLS community

TLS welcomes your letters by submitting them to us via  Whatsapp  or via email  [email protected]

This content, and any other content on TLS, may not be republished or reproduced without prior permission from TLS. Copying or reproducing our content is both against the law and against Halacha. To inquire about using our content, including videos or photos, email us at [email protected].

Stay up to date with our news alerts by following us on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook.
Got a news tip? Email us at [email protected], Text 415-857-2667, or WhatsApp 609-661-8668.

24 COMMENTS

Subscribe
Notify of

Answer the question below to prove you\'re human *

24 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
The Retzay
21 hours ago

You have a fair point but at the end of the day its all about what brings in money! Apparently this is what would get people excited and put in to the raffle therefore the organization puts it in to their raffle because they will bring in money through it. The advertising company is not sifting through the raffle options and deciding what is hashkafically correct or not as long as it seems not too wild they will keep their mouth shut as to not lose a customer. Now who else do you want to get involved with this?? Our Askanim?? What do they have to do with this?
Besides, having a raffle for expensive liquor isnt necessarily trying to promote drinking and glamorize it, its something that many people do, some people just like having a big collection of fancy bottles for the big simcha or other occasion that comes up from time to time! Its not automatically encouraging drinking to the next level. And a Lechayim here and there from an expensive bottle is not so bad! Maybe start attacking the other prizes like round trip ticket to florida where people are setting themselves up to see more pritzus! And lots of people suffer from Pritzus abuse even more than alcohol abuse? The answer is we pick and chose what bothers us and what to make a problem out of especially when we have no personal gain and its about someone elses gain suddenly all the problems come out but when its our gain we make sure how to fit it in to our Hashkafa!
Sincerely, A guy who is not a big drinker or beach goer.

Rebbitzen
Reply to  The Retzay
20 hours ago

Well said:)

Lakewood Yid
Reply to  The Retzay
16 hours ago

The prize could technically be used to give as gifts!

Josh
Reply to  The Retzay
15 hours ago

Sorry, you missed the writer’s point. It’s not all about the money. We have to live up to a higher expectation. It definitely is glorifying alcohol. All your comparisons are irrelevant.

Toeles Hayachid
Reply to  Josh
6 hours ago

the point is the writer missed the boat stop letting everything work you up and youll see youll have a much better life

Fred
21 hours ago

It has bothered me for years on Simchas Torah why do we need liquor to make us happy with the Torah?

The Retzay
Reply to  Fred
17 hours ago

You probably also wonder why on Purim we need wine to be happy with Hashem!
We are human and sometimes need some gasoline to get us going…

Lakewood Yid
Reply to  Fred
16 hours ago

It’s not in halacha, but a minhag yeshivos from Europe. I think wine is better than booz.

Ball of bus
21 hours ago

Right on

Victor
21 hours ago

maskim!

20 hours ago

Excellent!

ecrire un commente
20 hours ago

American culture and history judges drinking alcohol as evil. This isn’t a Torah view, this is a Puritan religious view.
People dress up these non-Jewish values in Jewish terminology, but things don’t convert that way.

If someone has a drinking problem, he has to deal with it. Like an obese person should not be frequenting takeout stores. But that should not be a reason to close down takeout stores or liquor stores.

d.b. cooper
Reply to  ecrire un commente
18 hours ago

The Puritans were NOT against drinking. They were much more fun-loving than you think

red herring
Reply to  ecrire un commente
15 hours ago

Whoever claimed we should shut down liquor stores?

Josh
Reply to  ecrire un commente
15 hours ago

I suggest you do a little research before you write such broad statements Jewish Values despise excess drinking . See rambam in many places

Shikur
20 hours ago

Why go after an issue we already do well?
“Jewish populations historically and statistically exhibit significantly lower rates of chronic alcoholism and problem drinking compared to most non-Jewish groups (such as Irish, Scandinavian, and general white or Western populations), though heavy drinking and addiction do still exist within the community. This difference is driven by a combination of cultural traditions, religious integration of alcohol, and genetic factors.
While general adult alcoholism rates in Western societies have historically hovered around 5% to 7%, studies long estimated Jewish alcoholism rates at under 1%, with dramatically lower rates of hospitalizations for alcohol psychosis.”

shmendrik
Reply to  Shikur
18 hours ago

The 1% is a denial number. That’s addmitted alcoholics in treatment. All the guys in shul having a handful to several shots every shabbos, is an alcoholic.

Josh
Reply to  Shikur
15 hours ago

Those of us that deal with the public, know that is a lot higher than that 1% figure. Even 1% in a community such as ours is hundreds of people. Destroyed families.dot. This is not what we need to promote!

Jeff
20 hours ago

Its sick out there and getting sicker, Bob Grant ,
Ish HaYashar Beinav, sad A langa golus

Lakewood Yid
16 hours ago

Yes, good point. Also, millions of children in the US have the same liver issues as alcoholics, as just as the liver must convert alcohol to fat – and too much overstrains it, so too it must convert sugar to fat.
This is besides other health issues from both.
Normal amounts of each are OK, but not getting drunk, as you said. Certainly not often. (Purim of course, and 4 kosos)

Yaakov
16 hours ago

Beautiful sentiment but it’s a symptom, not the root of the problem. We need to refocus our priorities and remember what we truly value and derive pleasure from in what used to be known as the ir HaTorah.

Coach
16 hours ago

If you win the raffle Ill take the liquor off your hands.

yanky
15 hours ago

we need a kol korei banning alcohol besides wine for kiddush

Stop & Think
12 hours ago

So, what would you rather see, a raffle for alcohol or a raffle for a Rolex ?


24
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x