I cannot believe I have to write this article, frankly. Believe me, I would much rather discuss something truly important like Hillary’s apparently criminal mishandling of classified information, Ohio Gov. John Kasich’s recent surge in polling, or perhaps the long-overdue expiry of the crony capitalist Export-Import Bank. In a Trump-less world, maybe I would be writing about Planned Parenthood’s barbaric and illegal harvesting and selling of fetal tissue. Instead, I find myself talking about The Donald, as virtually every talking head in the country has been for the last few weeks.
At the outset, let us establish what this article is not. It is not a prediction that Trump’s candidacy for president is on the verge of spontaneous combustion. Unlike most political observers in this country, I believe that the real estate mogul’s support within the GOP is both real and sustainable, though it remains to be seen whether he will actually sustain it. That’s not what this piece is about. This article is about why no real conservative should ever so much as consider voting for a RINO (Republican In Name Only) like Donald Trump. It’s about exposing a con man, a liberal in sheep’s clothing, whose candidacy threatens to put Hillary in the White House.
Donald Trump is simply not a conservative, and he never has been. Although he is now a registered independent (note: not a Republican), it wasn’t too long ago when The Donald was a registered Democrat. “I probably identify more as a Democrat,” he told CNN’s Wolf Blitzer in 2004. He went on to contend that “the economy does better under Democrats” and that “we’ve had pretty bad disaster under the Republicans.” Not exactly the strongest endorsement of conservative values. In addition, Trump has a long record of donating to Democratic candidates, including Hillary and Obama. How is going to explain that in a debate with Hillary? In 1999, Trump commented that “the Republicans are just too crazy right.” Those people he referred to as crazies are now the ones fueling his rise.
Trump has a long history of supporting unions, even indicating that union bosses do not currently have enough power and need to be brought “back to their rightful place at the table.” An integral component of conservatism, at least in my book, is to despise unions’ manipulation of workers and businesses, not promote it. Trump is also on the record in favor of an assault weapons ban, which would be an unconstitutional infringement of the Second Amendment’s right to bear arms. He has also written in favor a longer waiting period to purchase a gun. And if the prospective gun-buyer gets mugged or shot while waiting for his gun? Too bad, I guess. Recently, Trump has criticized gun control in general terms without acknowledging, explaining, or backing down from his past support. Donald Trump has called for higher taxes. He was pro-abortion before he was against it- conveniently, this flip-flop occurred right when he announced that he might run for president in 2012.
All this alone is enough to make Trump by far the most liberal of the seventeen Republicans aspiring for the GOP nomination. But I haven’t even mentioned the worst yet. In his 2000 book, Trump describes himself as “a liberal” on health care issues and calls on the federal government to “work out the details of a new single-payer plan.” For those who are not familiar with the term, a single-payer health care system is the same thing as socialized health care, in which the government controls and funds the entire health care system. It’s the system of choice for communist countries. It is far to the left of Obamacare. (Incidentally, Trump suggested that until his single-payer system becomes reality, we should implement a temporary plan that is exactly like Obamacare minus the individual mandate.) It boggles the mind that conservatives are coalescing around a candidate who has supported a communist health care plan- and tellingly, has not disavowed his past support until this very day.
It is for this reason that Donald Trump is scared to talk about actual issues. He has no policy director and no Issues tab on his website, and he just rails against illegals 24/7 without proposing any realistic, comprehensive solutions. He has demagogued John McCain, criticized Jeb Bush and Scott Walker (both of whom are infinitely more conservative than him), and gave out Lindsey Graham’s personal cell phone number. The only things he doesn’t talk about are issues and solutions. Because he can’t. Because the minute he starts talking policy, he will be forced to account for his decades-long and detailed record of unadulterated liberalism, and his supporters will abandon him en masse k’tinok habore’ach mibeis hasefer. Apparently, The Donald has a “foolproof” plan to beat ISIL. He just won’t tell us what it is, beyond finding the right general to wage war. (How he’ll be more successful than any other candidate at finding a good general is anyone’s guess.) He claims he will build a great massive wall on the southern border, but he won’t tell us how he will get congressional Democrats on board with that idea. Because he can’t, and he won’t. Newsflash: Every credible candidate in the GOP primary field, including Marco Rubio and Jeb Bush, wants to build an impenetrable fence on our southern border to stop the flow of illegal immigrants. But unlike Trump, they aren’t promising to do something that is outside the president’s power. The president does not have the constitutional authority to unilaterally build a wall on the border. Mr. Trump vows that he will be “the greatest jobs president that G-d ever created” and that he will “make America great again.” If you think these guarantees are short on specifics, it’s because they are. Trump cannot say he’ll lower taxes as president, because then he is going to be asked why in the past he wanted to raise taxes. He can’t talk about Obamacare, because then he will have to answer for his support of communist health care. In short, The Donald cannot talk about policy with any measure of detail, because then he will be exposed as the liberal con man that he is. The fact is that Donald Trump is so far to the left that some of his stances place him to the left of Hillary and Obama.
It may surprise some of my regular readers to learn that I used to be a Tea Party enthusiast. Being a staunch conservative, I was thrilled at first by the ascendancy of a widespread movement with the goal of advancing the conservative agenda. Why I quit the Tea Party is not the topic of this article, but there is one point that I want to bring out. During the 2012 cycle, when Trump floated the possibility of running for president then, I still identified with the Tea Party. (I was a Herman Cain supporter from the outset- is that Tea Party enough?) But not for one moment did I even consider backing Trump. Because Donald Trump is simply not a real Tea Party guy. He’s not a real conservative. He’s not even a moderate. The man is a liberal con man who is exploiting the Republican Party for his own personal gain (namely, the promotion of his brand and the pumping up of his ego). And he has a long, undeniable liberal record to prove it.
Of course, Trump’s liberalism is not the only problem with his bid for the Republican nomination. There is much to be said about the fact that every single credible poll of the broader electorate, including from USA Today/Suffolk University, Monmouth, PPP, and CNN, shows that Trump has a zero percent chance of winning a general rejection matchup even versus Bernie Sanders, let alone against Hillary. I could also go on for hours about how Trump’s volatile and unpredictable temperament would jeopardize our national security and turn us into even bigger global laughingstocks than we are under this president. (If you think Ronald Reagan would have denigrated American prisoners of war or would have given out a political opponent’s personal phone number “for fun,” you are clueless to the point of delusional.) But as valid as these points are, they should not be relevant, because no conservative Republican should even come close to voting for a leftist like Trump in the first place. Other arguments, while true, muddy the real argument against Trump: that he is not the least bit conservative. It is frankly laughable when someone says, “I like Ted Cruz and Donald Trump.” What these people are really saying is, “I support the most right-wing member of the Senate and also someone who supports socialized health care, increased union rights, higher taxes, and recently flip-flopped on abortion.” And has been pro-violating the Second Amendment. And donated thousands of dollars to the Democrat who he will probably square off against if he wins the GOP nod. In short, Ted Cruz and Donald Trump are on opposite ends of the political spectrum. That’s what matters. If you are a conservative and plan to vote for The Donald, you are lying to yourself. Period. Trump’s record is a story of liberalism if it is a story of anything (with inconsistency and flip-flopping a close second).
So where is Donald Trump’s support coming from? What about him appeals to so many Republicans from across the ideological spectrum of the party? Republicans are backing Trump because they are fed up with the political establishment. This simple fact is the most legitimate aspect of Trump’s campaign for president. Of course conservatives are fed up! We have a president who has given us Obamacare, Dodd-Frank, excessive carbon emissions regulation, and a bad deal with Iran that has more holes than a Trump golf course. He seems to believe that the Constitution is merely a suggestion and has moved unilaterally to grant amnesty to millions of illegal immigrants while doing little to stop the flow of migrants unlawfully flooding across our porous southern border. His Department of Justice has refused to act against “sanctuary cities” which are harboring these immigrants in blatant defiance of the law. Trump’s supporters are upset and I’m upset too, as any Republican should be! But Donald Trump, for all his angry rhetoric, is not the solution. As GOP strategist Rick Wilson put it a couple of weeks ago in his brilliant piece on Trump for Politico Magazine, “you think we’re dismissing the message, but we’re dismissing the messenger.” Donald Trump is not the right man to lead the conservative resurgence in the aftermath of Obama’s presidency, because on some issues he’s even less conservative than the president he wants to replace. Donald Trump is a great salesman, and he is a great manipulator too (as he himself proudly admits in his books). Any good salesman knows that you must identify a need that your prospective buyers have, real or imagined, in order to get them to buy your product. The Republican Party needs angry rhetoric, and Trump has stepped into the role of the angry outsider. But as we’ve demonstrated, he’s a fake. The Trump candidacy is a scam, as evidenced by the mogul’s liberal record. Do you really believe that Donald Trump will even try to solve the crisis at the border if he is elected president? What makes you think he won’t flip-flop on that issue, just as he already has on several others? Do you believe he will even try to repeal Obamacare, when he champions a health care system far more liberal? Do you think you can know whether or not he’ll stand with Israel when his record has all the direction of a leaf lost in a hurricane? What The Donald is for today is likely what he will be against tomorrow, and vice versa. His record is unambiguous about that; his frequent vacillations on issues like gun control, abortion, and party identity show that he cannot be trusted to stick to his guns. In my mind, the biggest proof that Trump doesn’t care about ideology as much as his personal promotion may be his standing threat to run as a third-party candidate if he doesn’t like “how well [he’s] treated” by the GOP. What is that statement if not an admission that a decision to run as an independent (and effectively destroy any chance the Republicans have at taking back the White House) will revolve solely around Trump and whether the Republican establishment hurts his feelings by attacking him too much? For Donald Trump, it’s all about him, not electing a conservative next November. And why should he care? After all, he’s never been a conservative anyway.
For anyone who is still deluding him/herself and still somehow believes that Trump might have a legitimate conservative bone in his body, let me leave you with a quote from The Donald that demonstrates just what a phony he is, even on his primary (and only) issue of immigration. Following Mitt Romney’s 2012 loss to Obama, our very own Donald Trump, the anti-illegal immigrant crusader who indicated that he thinks many or most Mexican immigrants are murderers and drug dealers, said this to explain Romney’s loss: “Comments and policies of Mitt Romney and other Republican candidates during this election were seen by Hispanics and Asians as hostile to them.” He added, “The Democrats didn’t have a policy for dealing with illegal immigrants, but what they did have going for them is they weren’t mean-spirited about it.” How can anyone be so naive and gullible as to believe that Trump’s professed anger at illegal immigrants is real when he made comments like this just three years ago? Like everything else in his extremely warped universe, Trump’s immigration rhetoric is all part of an elaborate act, the goal being self-promotion, as it always is with The Donald. His past comments on immigration prove that he’s not really such a hardliner. Donald Trump is attempting to exploit the Republican Party for his own personal gain. Let’s not help him succeed.
[TLS welcomes your opinion pieces by submitting them to [email protected]]
Well stated. The most troubling thing about Trump is what he is showing us about Americans. We must be really dumb to be supporting him over some many candidates of substance.
Your comments are beginning to lack any coherence. Bush and Christie have publicly opposed the wall. Rubio has supported blanket amnesty in the past, and has not supported the wall. Bush is Hillary Clinton in a suit, yet you bash Trump for being liberal.
In a new report submitted to Congress, it has been revealed that atop of the 1 million legal immigrants the U.S> accepts annually, Obama has approved another 1 million (a little more) guest workers per year in the guise of asylum seekers.
These legal residents have full access to all social benefits, add to that illegal immigration, and the U.S. is falling into an economic hole tat it will never be able to climb out of. (it is already over $17 trillion in debt).
Aside for that, trump is right about the trade deals. U.S. companies are not allowed to sell cars in South Korea, yet Hyundai can sell cars here. They have gone from being a shipbuilding company to the largest automaker in the world, while the U.S. was kept out of their market. The same is true in Japan and China in various industries
That is why Trump is popular. This election is not being defined by conservative or liberal, it is being defined by saving this country from falling into an abyss that it will never rise from
I am surprised that you don’t support Trump because if I remember correctly you are a big Bush fan and Trump is the best thing that ever happened to Bush. (He isn’t only helping Hillary.) Because Trump is getting so much attention he is ruining any opportunities the other candidates would be having now to try and overcome Bush’s lead. I do believe that Trump’s lead is not sustainable and in the end Bush will be the big winner, unfortunate but true.
Do you really think the other Republican contenders are comparable to fine China?!- but very cute title in any case.
Yosef
I too echo your position on Trump. The Donald would make a terrible President.
My biggest fear of Trump is his lack of basic humility. I’m not saying that the other candidates are extremely humble souls; they are not.
However, IMHO there is something about the brashness of Trump that really goes against the grain of leadership.
Some of our Presidents were great leaders and were never in YOUR FACE with their rhetoric.
In sum, The Donald fails in basic mentchlichkeit (decency). True we don’t need a lemelle for President, but we certainly don’t need an arrogant President.
PS. For the same reasons, I could never vote for Chris Christie. He too, in my opinion, lacks basic humility.
Even if Trump were conservative, his current ascendancy is typical elevation of style over substance. Besides that he could never win in Nov. 2016, his go-it-alone/my-way-or-the-highway persona could never successfully lead even a coherent platform to any success.
Finally, whatever your take on the other individual GOP candidates, Trump supporters should give some credit for people who have paid their dues and been in the trenches fighting for the values and issues on which they are now running.
One of the most troubling things about Trump and his policies is that under his reign my grandparents who immigrated legally after waiting many years in a DP camp would not have been allowed into this country while Mexicans who snuck over illeagally would be able to stay.
I would take trump over any of the candidates aside from Christy. Our president now is real nice guy who isnt “in ur face” and has midos and mentchlikiet…lets see where that took us..1.anyone paying for insurance saw the rates skyrocket and when it came time to use a professional doctor or need the use of an er saw themselves paying large large bills..2. He wasted billions building a website that crashed too many times to count 3. Anyone following the iran treaty saw our president give the worlds largest terrorist nation billions of dollars and ask for ummm uh nothing in return…3.when our president can get something done he blames everyone else…the latest being..prume minister netanyahu wont me with me! 4.our president takes more vacations that me and all my neighbors and family take all together. 5.he sides with every black tragedy..comparing them to his imaginary son.. but when white ppl are killed or hurt hes quiet for days on end and then says oh ye were sorry. 6.when someone disagrees with him he complains on national tv how no one is letting him do something. ..
So if u think about it the donald will be a better alternative. .hes against the nonhealth care plans hes against wasting our money..he has his own money for vacation and he talks straight. .
Id choose donald over our truth twisting agenda pushing care about noone aside from his legecagy obuma.
Legal Immigrant, I’m glad you’re legal but you are also totally confused. Trump is against ILLEGALS…our grandparents are safe.
I can’t believe that so many on this site actually would support Trump. The guy is a about as opposite to Torah hashkafa as you can get. I assume that he hires people to go around leaving nice comments about him (somewhat akin to the people he hired to cheer for him when he declared he was running.
#8- This piece is not about Obama!- I think that Stein would agree that almost anyone is a better choice than Obama- even the Donald. The point here is that we have a whole slew of Republican contenders with experience and real ideas- not just self centered, angry rhetoric who are being overshadowed by an inexpeienced ego maniac!
HUH, Trumps daughter is orthodox Yid so he may not be that bad.
Stein, I bet you voted for Schumer! Now there’s a guy you can all be proud of. How long did he ponder his opposition to the Iran deal, versus Trump who was against from the beginning. You make so many circular points, your position is foggy.
Please take a serious look at Marco Rubio. I think he is a breath of fresh air
great article, hope mashiach comes before trump can do any bad