Here’s a response to the previous Shabbos letters.
There have been a few letters lately about people sharing their personal Shabbos experiences. I humbly offer my own.
We are a simple Kollel family. We live near the Yeshiva in a small apartment packed with kids. Baruch Hashem we are not poor. Our children always have food in their bellies. The heating works. The bills get paid most of the time, somehow with quiet miracles. This is only the backdrop to our Friday night.
I come home from shul with my two boys and the moment I open the door I feel transported. The house is shining. The aroma drifting from the kitchen is the kind that wraps itself around your heart. The table is set with the Shabbos dishes we received at our chasuna. Some pieces are chipped and the silverware set is missing a few forks, but when you walk in you are met by something far more precious. You feel the warmth and the radiance of Shabbos. The candles fill the room with a soft glow.
Our furniture is all secondhand. Our dining room table is something we inherited from my grandparents. I am proud beyond words to sit at the same table that they sat at, sharing meals and stories and Shabbos zichronos. Our home is simple, sparking, clean, and glistening. On Shabbos it feels like it has been transformed into a place that is “mayain Olam Haba, where every corner hums with kedusha.
My kids jump off the couch and race over from reading and playing. I place a kiss on each precious head. Then I turn to my wife and wish her a warm good Shabbos. The kids settle down and gather around the table. Yes, they sometimes bicker about who sits where, but that is part of being a family.
We sing shalom aleichem and dishes chayil together. Everyone joins in, even my two-year-old. In our home each child receives a bracha. It is the most precious moment of my week. I try to think of the past week and offer each child a personal brocha, that the places they struggled should come together in the week ahead. After the bracha each child gets a kiss.
Then I make Kiddush over a simple bottle of sweet wine that tastes like kiddush is supposed to.
Under my challah cover are warm homemade challos. They are not sourdough. They are not artisan. They are simple challos made with love, the way challah was meant to be. Each child gets a generous slice. Then comes the gefilte fish with a chain and either mayonnaise or techina. We enjoy the fish and the children begin sharing the parsha. We always start with the youngest. The older kids listen and smile when their little siblings get something right.
When we sing zemiros, my two-year-old sits on my lap and sings along with everyone. Our zemiros are simple and sincere. I do not have a special voice, but I can carry a tune and my children love that I try.
I prepare a story before Shabbos and share it before we begin the soup. Then my wife brings out her golden chicken soup with lukshen and sometimes croutons.
After the soup, the younger children often wander off to play while the older ones say divrei Torah and we talk together about life and the parsha. There are moments in the middle of the meal when my wife and I exchange a quiet glance. It is a glance that says thank You Hashem for our family. Thank You for Shabbos. Thank You for giving us exactly the life we need.
The main course is chicken on the bone, potato kugel, and another kugel, sometimes apple, sometimes lokshen and also coleslaw. It tastes different on Shabbos. Better. Fuller. Sweeter. There is more singing.
I share something on the parsha in a child-friendly way. Dessert is simple. Ice cream. Homemade ices. Maybe a piece of cake.
Then we all bentch together. Loud and proud. The whole family together saying word for word.
Our meal is not long but it is real. And when it ends everyone feels special. Special about Shabbos. Special about being a Yid. Special about our home.
Some weeks feel our Shabbos feels more uplifting. Some weeks it feels a little more ordinary. But if you ask my children what their favorite time of the week is, they will answer without hesitation. Shabbos. And it is not because of the food or the treats. It is because of the togetherness.
This is our humble experience. My hope is that all those who have written about their Shabbos journeys will find the strength to quiet the noise, ignore the distractions, and focus on the greatest gifts Hashem has already placed in their hands.
And by the way, we would love to have you join us for a Shabbos meal.
TLS welcomes your letters by submitting them to us via Whatsapp or via email [email protected]

Thank you so beautiful
Thank you so much. My feelings exactly. And I believe that’s the majority. Sorry for those who aren’t zocheh. May your shabbos be enjoyfull as it’s meant to be. Oneg shabbos laasos es hashabos lidorosam. Means we should make and do shabbos in a way that it will make an impression and last “Lidorosom” .
💗
this letter totally ignores the truth, the reality, the challenges, and the pursuit of a salvation that so many Jewish neshamos aspire towards. the writer, obviously living in total fantasy, proclaims denial of today’s nisyonos, along with an aloof nearsightedness and subtle mocking of many fine Jewish families.
the letter is just plain not true. many do succeed but on a circuitous route, the impression that demographics and finances can alter the tikkun that each neshama must achieve is as stupid and blind as can be. i do not believe this was written by someone real, and i hope this person stays away from chinuch.
Disgusting.
I have a kollel friend that I’ve eaten seudos by near yeshiva area and this is exactly what his seuda looks like.
We are forever complaining that people don’t feel “connected”. So here we have somebody fortune enough to be connected. Your response- hate…..huh….?!
btw, many aspiring people feel very similar to the letter writer. Not everybody has negative feelings towards Yiddishkeit. Many actually feel and are very connected and it’s a source of strength. They don’t need the endless pursuit of self care of all the foolish therapy.
I don’t think the writer of that beautiful description of a Shabbos as it was meant to be is living in a fantasy. He is likely living with a young family that BH has not yet had to face the challenges that are out there. Because of the beauty of the Shabbos he describes, his children will be well-armed against the intrusions and seductions of the outside world. May the zechus of their worthy parents and their heilige Shabbosos stand them in good stead if and when they do face those challenges.
Life isn’t perfect, and no one’s pretending it is. But it is very important to highlighting the small, beautiful parts of Shabbos that do work. Those moments are real too, and people need to hear about them.
For many of us it’s those tiny flashes, a calm minute at the table, a child humming a niggun, the feeling when the candles are lit that keep us going. Focusing on them isn’t being unrealistic, it’s choosing to hold onto the parts of life that give us strength.
Not everything meaningful has to be dramatic. Sometimes focus on these simple positives are what keep a person from feeling overwhelmed.
Wrong. Just like the others posted about their shabbos, he’s posting about his shabbos. I know people who fit all 3 categories. They live in cities and communities all over theworld. These shabbos styles aren’t reserved for just Lakewood. They exist in every community in Brooklyn as well.
YOU need help!
The more we stick with tradition, the more likely it is that our children are going to stay on the right path. This is what Shabbos Seudas has looked like for many generations. Let’s not make any changes, and b’ezras hashem, our future generations should continue on this path
I’m sorry for you and your bitterness. You’re apparently are so removed from the reality described by this Kollel Yungerman, that you can’t even fathom it being true.
I dare not think of what led you to where you are today.
May Hashem allow you to be exposed to good people in this world, so that some of it might rub off on you, and that you find respite from the negativity that resides in your head.
It’s not so complicated here is the basic rundown, Fact 1: us yidden are part mundane part spiritual. Fact 2: shabbos is mayain oilom habba which means it is a spiritual connection to hashem, Fact 3: if a persons main focus in life is spiritual connection then shabbos rejuvenates him, but if his life is chasing mundane things then shabbos feels meaningless and numbing is needed to numb his neshama which craves spirituality!
jmusic.me/music/yerachmiel_begun_the_miami_boys_chior-miami_experience_2-shabbos
This sounds like the most beautiful ideal uplifting Shabbos. bH!
The difference is the first guy is in debt and you can pay your bills. You mentioned a kollel life. That usually comes with a support system. Be it Family/community/government programs etc. There is a tremendous burden on the struggling working middle class it is not fair to compare families that don’t have the same support.
I’m middle class and struggling with an easy heart because I daven that all my tax money should be directed to the yeshiva yungerleit, and this way I have a part in their learning
its not fair to compare middle class families where both parents are working for decent salaries with yungeleit who are struggling. The vast majority of long term kolel families do not have a support system after the first few years
Ok So who is supporting? And even if no one?(other then HKBH Himself) The difference is the kollel families choose that lifestyle and feel the struggles are worth the reward. But not everyone can sit and learn. The other guy chose to work and support his family the best he can and cant make ends meet so he feels no reward. Both those families seem like they live simplistic lifestyles. You still cant compare the menuchas hanefesh to a family who can pay their bills to one who can not.
the wife works hard, the husband has his kolel check, they live simply without extras, and hkb”h helps out. they definitly struggle. on the other hand much of the working class especially in lkwd goes over the top spending on luxuries (fancy cars, homes, clothes, etc) and then complaining that they can’t make ends meet.
שמח ראשי תיבות שבת מילה חודש
TALK ON TORAH ANYTIME
ON THE BEAUTY OF SHABBOS
BY RABBI SHOLOM AHRON EHRENFELD
SHIUR ID 267391
OR BY PHONE 7182982077
PRESS 9267391#
OMG you guys have KIDS both letters, how can you even think about complaining?? ALL of you, you write about your healthy children like its a given
How many people on this forum would give up everything to have a child of their own?? Get some perspective!!!!!!!!!
I know that was not the point of either letter, however when I read these posts that was all I was able to think.
Id keep liking this for an hour if I could
Sorry, people who are blessed with children do have challenges.
They are still blessed with children !!! No one should know what it means to be childless and they would gladly take the challenges that come with children.
here its matter of being able to afford extra luxurious with apparently no appreciation for the gifts they have
if one has to struggle for years to finally have a child they learn to appreciate the things they have
I agree. People who dont have to struggle to have children cannot phantom what it means to be childless.
I was waiting for someone to bring this up
Both writers describe what their shabbosos look like with or with our without challenges , and their takes
the second writer describes his shabbos like he’s being a saint by being happy, it ticked me off so badly, after struggling with infertility for so long, the guy has kids! how can he NOT be happy? so he doesnt have sourdough or a new table, he has healthy kids!!!!
Thanks for rolling some perspective in
I was waiting for someone to bring this up
The write is sounding all saint-like by being happy in his apartment without sourdough challah, or the other writer who was all upset for the same reasons
All I was thinking was ‘how can they NOT be happy they have healthy kids’
I mean seriously, yes there are struggles in the world even with children but please, this shabbos is what we’ve been dreaming of for years! sourdough or no sourdough, a shabbos table with precious children sitting around it ….
We are not a kollel family and this Shabbos description is totally relatable to us. Our whole family, ages 2-18 look forward to Shabbos. Its relaxing, rejuvenating, beautiful family time that we wait for all week. We sing, say divrei Torah, play games and rest. We dont only have simple foods but dont go crazy. We make special things for Shabbos like sour dough in addition to challah and the occasional home made meat board. There are many many yidden who feel joy and connection to Shabbos. Please dont disgrace Shabbos with all this negativity.