A Note About an Unfortunate Article

By: Rabbi Chaim Dovid Zwiebel. A number of people have called my attention to an anti-Agudath Israel screed that was recently published as an op-ed column in a Jewish periodical. The article defames Rabbi Moshe Sherer z’l, distorts the words of my colleague Rabbi Avi Shafran, and slanders the Agudah. I feel I must respond.

The article insinuates that the Agudah, going back to 1980 when Rabbi Sherer served as president of the organization and continuing still through today, supports Democrats over Republicans to the detriment of our community’s interests, and does so for financial gain. Thus, writes the author, “the late Rabbi Moshe Sherer of Agudath Israel had promised President Jimmy Carter the Orthodox vote [in the 1980 presidential election]. We can only speculate what he got in return for choosing the spendthrift candidate over the moral candidate.”

To anyone who knew Rabbi Sherer, the notion that this legendary Agudah leader who enjoyed the absolute trust of the greatest Gedolei Yisroel would favor a “spendthrift” political candidate in order to get something “in return,” is beyond preposterous and deeply offensive. What is the author’s source for Rabbi Sherer’s alleged promise to President Carter?

And what is his source for the equally startling assertion that Vice President Walter Mondale called Rabbi Sherer to complain about people wearing Reagan buttons on Ocean Parkway, to which Rabbi Sherer supposedly replied that they were disciples of a “fringe rabbi” who had no real following in the community? Whether any rabbonim encouraged people to wear Reagan buttons I do not know, but it’s a bit hard to believe that Vice President Mondale would place a special call to complain about the buttons of Ocean Parkway. And it’s even harder to believe that Rabbi Sherer would denigrate a choshuve rav in conversations with any other people, let alone the Vice President of the United States.

How does the author know the details of these alleged conversations? Were they disclosed in the public memoirs of President Carter and Vice President Mondale? Have any historians of that era written about these alleged conversations? Did Rabbi Sherer confide in him? Did Rabbi Sherer reveal this information at the Agudah convention? Did it get written up in the Jewish Observer? Are there minutes of these conversations in the Agudath Israel archives?

I would venture to say not. I would venture to say these conversations probably never took place. And yet they are cited in the article as confirmed fact, and for one reason alone: to attack the Agudah.

The author intensifies that attack by pointing to one of Rabbi Avi Shafran’s recent articles in which he opines that most Democrats, including Vice President Biden, are reasonable people and generally supportive of Israel. This opinion, in the author’s eyes, constitutes “criminal naivite and negligence at best, cynical manipulation and distortion at worst.”

Further, it proves that “Rabbi Avi Shafran and Agudath Israel were still engaging in their misguided behavior from 1980.” (Just to make sure his readers understand what’s really on his mind, the author congratulates himself for his temperate language in describing the Agudah’s behavior as simply “misguided”; “the alternative,” he ominously proclaims, “is too awful to contemplate” – thereby inviting his readers to engage in precisely such awful contemplation.)

While it is true that Rabbi Shafran serves as Agudath Israel’s public affairs director, he also frequently speaks in his own voice as well, not as a spokesman for the Agudah but as a private individual. His column about the Democratic Party was an expression of his personal views, and cannot be attributed more generally to the Agudah.

But beyond that, it is dismaying that the anti-Agudah op-ed columnist cites Rabbi Shafran’s article so selectively, treating it as a de facto endorsement of Mr. Biden and the Democratic Party. In fact, Rabbi Shafran took pains to disavow any such endorsement. Here’s what he wrote:

“None of the above is intended as a call to support Mr. Biden. There is ample and understandable enthusiasm in our community for President Trump, who has taken a number of steps to show support for Israel. And there are other issues where our stances resonate with the Republican ones. Personally, I am a registered Republican, and have, over decades, most often voted for Republican candidates.

“I’m suggesting only one thing: that we refrain from demonizing either of our country’s major political parties.”

Finally, a word to the periodical that published this anti-Agudah screed: What conceivable to’eles is there in attacking Rabbi Sherer? What heter is there to publicly denigrate an organization that works tirelessly and effectively under the leadership of gedolei Yisroel to promote the interests of the klal?

The writer’s words, were they true, would be lashon hora of the worst sort. As it is, they are worse, a hotzo’as shem ra, an inexcusable slander.

This content, and any other content on TLS, may not be republished or reproduced without prior permission from TLS. Copying or reproducing our content is both against the law and against Halacha. To inquire about using our content, including videos or photos, email us at [email protected].

Stay up to date with our news alerts by following us on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook.

**Click here to join over 20,000 receiving our Whatsapp Status updates!**

**Click here to join the official TLS WhatsApp Community!**

Got a news tip? Email us at [email protected], Text 415-857-2667, or WhatsApp 609-661-8668.

9 COMMENTS

  1. Rabbi Shafran is certainly entitled to his opiniion. However, since he is, in fact, the director of public affairs for Agudah, any opinions that are his own should be headed with a disclaimer that he is NOT speaking on behalf of Agudah. In addition, any descriptive blurb that is included with his opinion should not state his “yichus” as public affair director of Agudah.

  2. The author signed his name so it should be easy to verify how he knows the stories (which does seem a little extreme) but on the same token anyone who reads shafran’s stuff knows he supports Biden and Harris even though he put in that one paragraph that makes him officially neutral. Also, the main point of the author is still correct. Frum organizations pander to Democrats. If you want to stay neutral so be silent but if you want to support then accept the criticism

    • The Agudah “panders to democrats”?
      Really?
      On what basis do you say that? Did you not even read the above article that you are commenting on which decries those, such as yourself, who fling accusations off the top of their head?

      Is your proof that Agudah ‘panders’ to democrats the fact that they deal with current elected officials? That wouldnt be pandering. That would be, wait, theres a word for it, oh, um, dealing with elected officials!

    • Frum organizations pander to all political parties, democrats and republicans. Some people only notice when they do so to the Democrats.
      And there is a valid reason for that. Organizations need to serve, they don’t have the luxury of following ideologies. If the Torah tells us not to do something, they cannot and do not do it. But the Torah does not support the Republicans any more than it does the Democrats, neither of them are Torah. The Torah did not support the czars, poretz’ and sultans to whom we pandered throughout our history.
      We do what is necessary for our survival, we do not follow strange ideologies.

  3. to Mr. Interesting,
    You seem to be supporting the writer of the op-ed.
    You think that someone who makes his opinions public should be personally attacked with lies?
    You think that to attack someone who is dead and can’t reply to what might be total lies is ok (this is not taking into account what a great man rabbi sherer was)?
    Rabbi Zwiebel was taking issue with attacks that are at the very best uncalled for and at the worst (and probably accurately) absolute slander. Yet, you defend.
    Did Rabbi Zwiebel suggest that perhaps the writer of the op-ed had ulterior motives? No, because he is a mensch, something which most certainly cannot be attributed to the writer of the op-ed.

  4. Why shouldn’t we demonize the other party when they openly support, defend, and endorse rabid Jew haters in Congress, there was no reason for the speaker of the house to endorse the 2 Jew haters Omar and tlaib in their primaries except to court the democtts party base which is increasingly anti Israel and anti Semitic. When one party openly supports criminals, rioters, thugs, and looters they must be demonized. When one party openly supports the banning of religious freedom and calls for the prosecution of anyone who has religious beliefs that don’t comport to their radical beliefs they must be demonized. The democrat party now is moving more left and the base is becoming more and more anti semitic, they must be demonized and called out for it. The Democrat party chair and others have said that the party has no room for anyone who doesnt support their radical anti Torah agenda, so how could any frum Jew vote for such a party let alone openly support them or be a member of it. We must vote for the republicans and kick Spartacus Booker out of office.

    • Trump’s America, too blind to see. There are racist in both parties. No one has gotten kicked out of the Democratic Party, but Justin Amash was.
      Look how Mitt Romney is being treated by Trump.

  5. Tank you Rabbi Zweibel for your carefully worded letter. May Rabbi Scherer memory be a blessing. To those of you who are posting angry posts, please learn from Moshe Rabbeinu and what happened every time he let anger take hold of him.

Comments are closed.